Fact-check analysisVerified as of July 26, 2025Curated by FactVerify
Mostly False

In a major rebuke of Donald Trump and Tulsi Gabbard, the CIA Officer responsible for the intelligence report about Russia’s election interference schemes just said that Trump and Gabbard are lying in their claims suggesting Russia didn’t interfere in our elections. Wow.

There is no verified public statement from the CIA officer responsible for the 2017 intelligence report explicitly accusing Donald Trump and Tulsi Gabbard of lying about Russia’s election interference; the claim conflates complex and disputed political narratives with direct personal accusations that are not supported by authoritative sources.

Gabbard and White House 'lying' about intel on Russian interference in 2016, ex-CIA official says

Gabbard and White House 'lying' about intel on Russian interference in 2016, ex-CIA official says

Source: nbcnews.com

At a glance

Key Evidence

Verified July 26, 2025
The reporting

What the Evidence Shows

The input claim asserts that a CIA officer responsible for the intelligence report on Russia’s election interference has directly stated that Donald Trump and Tulsi Gabbard are lying about Russia not interfering in U.S. Elections. Breaking down this claim, it involves: 1) identification of a CIA officer responsible for the 2017 intelligence assessment on Russian interference, 2) a direct public rebuke or accusation of lying against Trump and Gabbard, and 3) the context of their claims denying Russian interference.

Reviewing available evidence from recent credible news sources reveals no direct quote or verified statement from any CIA officer explicitly calling Trump and Gabbard liars. Instead, the discourse centers around Tulsi Gabbard, who as Director of National Intelligence (DNI), has publicly challenged the consensus view on Russian interference, alleging manipulation or politicization of intelligence by the Obama administration.factcheck.orgfactcheck.orgGabbard's Misleading 'Coup' Claim Meanwhile, some former intelligence officials have criticized Gabbard’s reinterpretation of the intelligence as misleading or inaccurate.nbcnews.comnbcnews.comGabbard and White House 'lying' about intel on Russian interference in 2016,...

Donald Trump has historically disputed Russia’s interference claims, but no authoritative CIA official has publicly issued a direct personal rebuke labeling him a liar in recent statements. The closest relevant source is Susan Miller, a former CIA official involved in the 2017 assessment, who affirmed that intelligence on Russian interference was solid and accurate but did not single out Trump or Gabbard with personal accusations.nbcnews.comnbcnews.comGabbard and White House 'lying' about intel on Russian interference in 2016,...

The claim appears to conflate political disputes over interpretations of intelligence with an alleged direct statement from a CIA officer accusing specific individuals of lying. This is a significant logical leap without supporting evidence. The political context is highly polarized, with Gabbard and Trump promoting narratives that challenge established intelligence conclusions, while many intelligence community veterans defend those conclusions. However, no verified source confirms the exact claim as stated.

Therefore, while there is ongoing debate about Russia’s election interference narrative and political figures’ statements about it, the specific assertion that a CIA officer responsible for the report has just said Trump and Gabbard are lying is not supported by credible evidence and misrepresents available information.

Primary trail

Verified Sources4

Gabbard and White House 'lying' about intel on Russian interference in 2016,...

nbcnews.com
Open source

Tulsi Gabbard calls out media for ignoring Russia intel findings

foxnews.com
Open source

Gabbard's Misleading 'Coup' Claim

factcheck.org
Open source
Keep exploring

Where to go next

Continue with the evidence, catch up on the week, or save this check for later.

Share or return