Lawmakers move to have Jack Smith DISBARRED after reports he and the FBI spied on GOP senators.

The claim that lawmakers have moved to have Jack Smith disbarred after reports he and the FBI spied on GOP senators is misleading because while multiple sources confirm that the FBI, under Special Counsel Jack Smith, obtained phone records of GOP senators as part of a January 6 investigation, there is no verified evidence of an official disbarment effort against Smith, and the nature of the surveillance was limited to phone metadata rather than content or illegal spying.

Jack Smith investigation into January 6 obtained phone records of GOP lawmakers, Republicans say - CNN Politics
Source: cnn.com

Jack Smith investigation into January 6 obtained phone records of GOP lawmakers, Republicans say - CNN Politics
Source: cnn.com

At a glance

Key Evidence

Verified October 8, 2025

Multiple sources confirm FBI obtained phone metadata of GOP senators under Jack Smith's authority during the January 6 probe.cnn.com nytimes.com
The surveillance involved call logs only, not content or wiretapping.nbcnews.com politico.com
No credible source reports any formal disbarment proceedings against Jack Smith initiated by lawmakers.

The reporting

What the Evidence Shows

Multiple reputable sources report that during the January 6 investigation, the FBI, authorized by Special Counsel Jack Smith, obtained court orders to collect phone records (metadata such as call times and durations) of several Republican senators and lawmakers. This action has been publicly criticized by GOP senators and commentators as political weaponization or unconstitutional surveillance.cnn.com nytimes.com However, these reports clarify that the FBI did not 'tap' or listen to phone conversations but analyzed call logs only.+2 more

There is significant political backlash from Republican lawmakers and figures like Sen. Tommy Tuberville and former President Donald Trump who have condemned Smith harshly.youtube.com newsweek.com Some partisan outlets and commentators describe the surveillance as 'illegal spying' or 'unconstitutional', but these characterizations are disputed or lack independent legal confirmation.+3 more

Importantly, none of the sources provide credible evidence or official confirmation that any formal move to disbar Jack Smith has been initiated by lawmakers or legal authorities. The claim about disbarment appears to be an extrapolation or political rhetoric rather than a documented fact.

In summary, while it is true that Jack Smith authorized FBI collection of GOP senators' phone records during an investigation, the claim about lawmakers moving to disbar him is unsubstantiated by available evidence and thus misleading.

Primary trail