There is no clear evidence from the provided sources that the CDC under Trump took down a public database specifically showing that red states have higher homicide rates than blue states.
Unverified
The Trump CDC just took down its public database showing that red states have higher homicide rates than blue states.
The “Red” vs. “Blue” Crime Debate and the Limits of Empirical Social Science - Manhattan Institute
Source: manhattan.institute
At a glance
Verified August 22, 2025Key Evidence
Multiple sources confirm red states tend to have higher homicide or gun death rates than blue states.
manhattan.institutemanhattan.instituteThe “Red” vs. “Blue” Crime Debate and the Limits of Empirical Social Science
forbes.comforbes.comRed States Have Higher Gun Death Rates Than Blue States. Here’s Why+1 more
Some blue counties and cities have higher homicide rates than red counties, complicating simple red vs. Blue comparisons.
heartlanddailynews.comheartlanddailynews.comFACT CHECK: Blue Cities Inflate Red States’ Homicide Rates (Commentary)
axios.comaxios.comSome blue cities in red states have the nation's highest homicide rates, FBI...+1 more
No source mentions any CDC database removal or alteration related to this data (all sources).
The reporting
What the Evidence Shows
The claim that the 'Trump CDC' removed a public database comparing homicide rates by political affiliation of states is not directly supported or mentioned in any of the provided sources. None of the articles discuss a CDC database being taken down or altered.
Multiple sources confirm that red states generally have higher homicide or gun death rates than blue states, but also emphasize complexity:
- Some blue counties and cities have higher homicide rates than red counties.
dailysignal.comdailysignal.comFACT CHECK: How Blue Cities and Counties Inflate Red States' Homicide Rates
- Blue cities within red states can have very high homicide rates.
biztoc.combiztoc.comSome blue cities in red states have the nation's highest homicide rates, FBI...
The sources focus on analyzing homicide data and political geography but do not mention any government action to remove or restrict access to such data.
The claim references a specific event (database removal) which would likely be documented in official records or news reports; none appear in the search results.
The term 'Trump CDC' is ambiguous since the CDC is a federal agency that spans multiple administrations; no source attributes database removal to the Trump administration or CDC.
Therefore, while the general pattern of higher homicide rates in red states is supported, the specific claim about database removal by the Trump CDC lacks evidence in these sources.
Primary trail
Verified Sources7
Open source