This is due to low rating because of low budget cgi animation on indonesia and this film “Merah Putih: One for All” is a propaganda.

The film 'Merah Putih: One for All' has received criticism for its low-budget CGI animation quality and has been labeled by some netizens as propaganda, though it was intended as a patriotic nationalistic film.

"Merah Putih: One For All" — Inside the Controversy Surrounding Indonesia’s Patriotic Animated Film - Best Breaking News and Beyond: Singapore, Batam and some say JB
Source: batamnewsasia.com

At a glance

Key Evidence

Verified August 15, 2025

The film was criticized on social media for poor visual graphics and low-quality animation.dw.com
The production budget was around Rp 6.7 billion, which some consider low for CGI animation standards and have called it a propaganda project.kaltimpost.jawapos.com
Producers positioned the film as a patriotic call for unity and nationalism.batamnewsasia.com

The reporting

What the Evidence Shows

The animated film 'Merah Putih: One for All' was released in August 2025 to coincide with Indonesia's Independence Day celebrations, aiming to promote nationalism and unity among children and the general public.batamnewsasia.com letterboxd.com

The film has faced significant criticism from Indonesian netizens and media for its poor CGI animation quality, which many viewers found substandard compared to other successful animated films.dw.com kompas.id

Additionally, the film's funding, reported at approximately Rp 6.7 billion, and its nationalistic theme have led some critics and social media users to label it as a propaganda project rather than purely entertainment or educational content.kaltimpost.jawapos.com

Official responses from government officials have been limited or non-committal, with some ministers not commenting due to lack of viewing the film.voi.id

Despite the negative reception regarding animation quality and accusations of propaganda, the producers intended the film as a patriotic cinematic gift to inspire Indonesian youth.batamnewsasia.com

In summary, the claim that the film suffers from low-budget CGI animation and is considered propaganda by some is supported by multiple sources, though the intent behind the film was nationalistic inspiration rather than overt propaganda.

Primary trail