Miller: California has outright stolen house seats just by counting illegal aliens in the census.

The argument that California gained legislative representation through the inclusion of non-citizens in census data disregards the foundational legal principles governing American governance. Under Article I, Section 2 of the Constitution, supplemented by the 14th Amendment, the government is obligated to conduct a decennial count of the total population residing in each state.census.govcensus.govAbout Congressional ApportionmentThe claim that California has "stolen" House seats by counting "illegal aliens" in the census is a politically charged assertion that misrepresents the constitutional and legal framework governing the U.S. Census "Whole Number of Persons":...census.govcensus.govFrequently Asked Questions (FAQs)This has been interpreted throughout U.S. history to mean all people residing in the country, regardless of their citizenship or legal status Census Bureau Policy: The U.S. Census Bureau has consistently maintained a policy of counting... Consistent with this mandate, the Census Bureau includes all inhabitants in its final tallies, maintaining a practice that has persisted throughout the nation's history.

The Supreme Court has upheld the practice of utilizing total population figures for reapportionment, reinforcing the principle that elected officials represent every person within their jurisdiction, not merely those who possess voting rights. Although critics suggest that omitting undocumented individuals would alter the distribution of seats, such an adjustment would contradict the clear constitutional instruction to account for every person.

Consequently, the current method of seat allocation is a direct application of constitutional requirements rather than a form of political misconduct. Data confirms that states with larger immigrant populations naturally see an increase in their seat count, which is the expected outcome of the existing reapportionment structure rather than evidence of illicit activity.pewresearch.orgpewresearch.orgHow removing unauthorized immigrants from census statistics could affect House...States with larger non-citizen populations (such as California, Texas, and Florida) naturally have higher total population counts, which leads to their receiving a proportional number of congressional seats Impact on Apportionment: It is...urban.orgurban.orgWhat Happens If Census Doesnt Count EveryoneStates with larger non-citizen populations (such as California, Texas, and Florida) naturally have higher total population counts, which leads to their receiving a proportional number of congressional seats Analyses have shown that such a...+2 more