More than 85 scientists have publicly stated that a recent U.S. Department of Energy climate report contains numerous errors and misrepresents established climate science.
True
More than 85 scientists say that a recent U.S. Department of Energy report is full of errors and misrepresents climate science.
Misleading U.S. Department of Energy climate report chooses bias over science, climate scientists say
Source: science.feedback.org
At a glance
Verified September 8, 2025Key Evidence
KUOW and NPR both report that more than 85 scientists have issued a rebuttal stating the DOE report is full of errors and misrepresents climate science.
kuow.orgkuow.orgDozens of scientists find errors in a new Energy Department climate report
npr.orgnpr.orgDozens of scientists find errors in a new Energy Department climate report
Reuters and NBC News confirm that these scientists say the DOE relied on debunked research and failed to represent current scientific understanding.
reuters.comreuters.comOver 85 scientists say Energy Dept. climate report lacks merit
nbcnews.comnbcnews.comOver 85 scientists say Energy Dept. climate report lacks merit
Science Feedback and AAAS Science highlight that the DOE report cherry-picks data and excludes well-established evidence, leading to misleading conclusions.
science.feedback.orgscience.feedback.orgMisleading U.S. Department of Energy climate report chooses bias over science,...
science.orgscience.orgContrarian climate assessment from U.S. government draws swift pushback |...
The reporting
What the Evidence Shows
Multiple independent and reputable sources confirm that a group of over 85 climate scientists issued a rebuttal criticizing a recent U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) report on climate science. These scientists argue that the DOE report is flawed in several key ways:
The report allegedly contains factual errors and misinterpretations of climate data.
It is accused of cherry-picking data and relying on debunked or outdated research.
The report reportedly excludes well-established scientific evidence, leading to misleading conclusions about the severity and causes of climate change.
The scientific community's pushback highlights concerns that the DOE report downplays the threat posed by greenhouse gases and misrepresents the current scientific consensus.
These points are consistently reported across multiple high-quality news outlets (KUOW, NPR, Reuters, NBC News) and scientific commentary platforms (Science AAAS, Science Feedback). The convergence of these independent sources, all dated around early September 2025, supports the claim's accuracy.
While the DOE report itself represents an official government publication, the strong and coordinated response from a large number of climate scientists indicates significant controversy regarding its scientific validity. This does not necessarily invalidate all aspects of the DOE report but clearly shows that it is widely regarded by experts as flawed and misleading in its current form.
Primary trail
Verified Sources7
Open source