Poll data from 2025 indicates that a majority of Americans, around 59-60%, support deporting or arresting only undocumented immigrants who have committed crimes, implying that many do not believe those without criminal records should be detained.
59% of Americans don't believe undocumented immigrants who have lived in the US for several years with no criminal record should be arrested and detained.

Immigrants' Rights - American Civil Liberties Union
Source: aclu.org
Key Evidence
The Pew Research Center's March 2025 report shows that most White (59%) and Asian (60%) adults who support some deportations say immigrants living illegally should be deported if they have committed nonviolent crimes.
pewresearch.orgpewresearch.orgViews on deportations and arrests of immigrants in the US illegally The Fox News poll from 2025 similarly reports that 60% back deporting only immigrants with criminal charges.
foxnews.comfoxnews.comFox News Poll: 60% back deporting only immigrants with criminal charges
What the Evidence Shows
The claim that 59% of Americans do not believe undocumented immigrants who have lived in the US for several years without a criminal record should be arrested and detained aligns closely with recent polling data. According to a March 2025 Pew Research Center survey, a significant portion of Americans support deporting undocumented immigrants primarily if they have committed crimes, especially nonviolent ones.
Similarly, a Fox News poll from 2025 found that about 60% of respondents support deporting only those immigrants charged with crimes, indicating a reluctance to endorse arrest or detention of undocumented immigrants without criminal records. These findings reflect a broader trend in public opinion favoring more targeted immigration enforcement rather than broad arrests or detentions. While exact phrasing and percentages may vary slightly between polls, the general sentiment supports the claim's core assertion.
However, the claim does not specify the poll source or exact wording, which is important for precise verification.